NAVIGATING THE EVOLVING INSURANCE LANDSCAPE: A STRATEGIC APPROACH TO EPLI AND WORKERS’ COMPENSATION

BY Evan Mitchell

Senior Vice President
Armhr

March 2025

 

In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, PEOs face unprecedented challenges in managing their insurance programs. With two decades of experience in the PEO industry, I’ve observed firsthand how market conditions, regulatory frameworks, and client expectations have transformed, requiring the need for PEOs to develop a resilient strategy for Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) and workers’ compensation programs that align with the current market realities.

The industry has undergone significant shifts in the past 20 years, and strategies that were effective five years ago are no longer sufficient. To stay competitive, PEOs must adapt their insurance approaches to address emerging risks while maintaining cost-effective pricing structures.

UNDERSTANDING CURRENT MARKET DYNAMICS

The insurance market is hardening, leading to rising premiums across all lines of coverage, particularly EPLI. This trend is driven by several factors, including an uptick in employment-related claims, expanding workplace regulations, and the ongoing impact of post-pandemic workplace transformations. The shift towards remote work has introduced new liability considerations that many PEOs had not previously incorporated into their risk assessments.

At Armhr, our proprietary underwriting approach is delivering exceptional results in this challenging environment. By moving beyond conventional risk assessment models and integrating predictive analytics with industry-specific data, we can offer more precise and proactive solutions.

MODERNIZING WORKERS’ COMPENSATION PROGRAMS

Workers’ compensation remains a fundamental component of PEO service offerings, but its management requires a modernized approach. Successful strategies include:

Proactive Safety Programs: Investing in comprehensive safety training and monitoring systems is no longer optional; it is a necessity. PEOs that prioritize safety initiatives see marked reductions in claims frequency and severity. This approach not only ensures regulatory compliance but also fosters a culture of safety that benefits both clients and carriers.

Data-Driven Decision Making: Leveraging advanced analytics to develop granular risk profiles allows for more precise pricing and improved risk management strategies. At Armhr, our underwriting expertise enables us to transcend traditional industry classifications and provide tailored solutions.

EPLI: NAVIGATING A COMPLEX LANDSCAPE

Employment Practices Liability Insurance has grown increasingly intricate due to the surge in claims related to discrimination, harassment, and wrongful termination. To navigate this complexity effectively, PEOs should focus on:

Customized Coverage Solutions: The era of one-size-fits-all EPLI coverage is over. Tailoring coverage to specific industry sectors, company sizes, and risk profiles ensures that clients receive optimal protection. Developing modular coverage options allows for flexibility as client needs evolve.

Preventive Measures: Providing clients with robust, proactive HR training programs, documentation systems, and well-defined policies significantly reduces claim frequency and enhances the PEO’s negotiating position with carriers.

STRATEGIC RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PEOS

Based on our extensive experience at Armhr, the following strategies are necessary for optimizing insurance programs:

  • Invest in Technology: Implementing sophisticated claims tracking and risk management systems yields substantial returns through lower premiums and improved loss ratios.
  • Build Strategic Carrier Partnerships: Instead of focusing solely on cost, PEOs should cultivate relationships with carriers that understand the PEO model and are committed to innovative solutions.
  • Enhance Client Education: Providing clients with accessible, comprehensive training programs helps them maintain better claims histories, ultimately benefiting all stakeholders.

LOOKING AHEAD

As the insurance landscape continues to evolve, PEOs must stay proactive in anticipating emerging risks such as cybersecurity threats, evolving remote work arrangements, and shifting employment regulations. At Armhr, we are already preparing for these challenges by integrating forward-thinking strategies into our risk management approach.

Success in managing insurance programs requires more than securing the right coverage; it demands the creation of integrated risk management solutions that protect PEOs and their clients while maintaining cost efficiency. PEOs that embrace innovation, invest in technology, and proactively manage risks will be well-positioned to thrive in this dynamic environment.

SHARE


RELATED ARTICLES

RISK

TIME ON YOUR SIDE: FIVE SCRAPPY WAYS YOUR PEO CAN USE AI TO SHRINK THE GROUP HEALTH SALES CYCLE

In your group health sales cycle, time is of the essence. Shorter sales cycles generally lead to larger volumes, higher revenues, more satisfied account execs, and repeat customers, especially for an annual purchase like group health insurance. You can shrink the time you turn a lead into a customer by adding a speedy new member to your sales team: artificial intelligence. AI can help you close deals faster than your competitors can get their boots on.

BY Kaitlyn Fischer

September 2023

5 QUESTIONS TO ASK A CLOUD SERVICE PROVIDER ABOUT CYBERSECURITY

One of the questions I’m frequently asked by PEOs is simple: Is the cloud safe?  Actually, this is a trickier question than it seems. The answer is yes, of course, but like any internet-based endeavor, there are certainly many caveats. Cloud security requires you to think about security differently than on-premise security or data center security.

BY Dwayne Smith

March 2023

DISASTER RECOVERY FOR PEOS

Disasters are inevitable, and their timing is unpredictable. Preparing your company and employees before disaster strikes can make the difference between a catastrophe or an inconvenience. While no one wants to experience a business disruption, especially any technology-related disruption, there are many reasons that you could end up in that position.

BY Hamesh Chawla

March 2023

NEXT GENERATION PEO RISK DEPARTMENTS

As we all know, the year is 2023, and as PEO risk managers it is important that we embrace the title of a Bob Dylan classic: “The Times They Are A-Changin'.” Given the myriad of changing issues facing the PEO risk manager, a detailed point-by-point examination of the evolving issues would be too lengthy to illuminate within the pages of this article. That being said, this article will focus on two emerging and evolving issues that the PEO risk manager should embrace: dynamic risk analysis and next generation risk department staffing.  

BY Scott Johnson

April 2023

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad for Sentara Health Plans