RETHINKING THE PEO SALES FUNNEL

The world of B2B sales is undergoing a dramatic shift—and the PEO industry is not exempt. In fact, if your pipeline development strategy still relies heavily on traditional outbound tactics and seller-led conversations, you may be missing a significant percentage of today’s buying activity.

According to the 2024 B2B Buyer Experience Report by 6sense, today’s buyers are more independent, better informed, and further along in their decision-making process before engaging with a sales rep. The data is striking:

  • B2B buyers are nearly 70% through their purchasing process before they ever speak to a seller.
  • Buyers initiate first contact in more than 80% of cases—not the other way around.
  • Approximately 85% of buyers have already defined their purchase requirements before reaching out to vendors.

These statistics are a wake-up call for PEOs still relying on conventional sales playbooks. Let’s unpack what this means—and how PEOs can evolve to meet modern buyers long before they ever pick up the phone.

THE PEO SALES PROCESS IS NOW BUYER-LED, NOT SELLER-LED

Historically, PEO sales have been driven by relationship-building and consultative selling, often initiated through cold calls or networking events. While these tactics still play a role, they’re no longer the primary way buyers engage.

That buyers are 70% through their journey before speaking to a sales rep for the first time signals a major change: your prospects are researching independently. They’re reading articles, reviewing comparisons, asking peers, and consuming digital content well in advance.

Implication for PEOs: If you’re not visible in the digital spaces where research happens, you’re invisible to your next client. Content marketing, SEO, and thought leadership—not just lead generation—must be foundational to your strategy. The earlier you enter the buyer’s awareness, the better chance you have of making the shortlist.

PROSPECTS REACH OUT WHEN THEY’RE READY – BE READY

With over 80% of first contact initiated by the buyer, sales power dynamics have shifted. Rather than being “sold to,” buyers arrive with specific needs and expectations—and they engage only when ready.

For PEOs, this makes it essential that your website (and your perspective on the challenges prospects are dealing with) are easy to find and easy to engage with—especially for buyers who prefer autonomy.

Implication for PEOs: Create low-friction pathways that help buyers self-educate. Offer a mix of gated and ungated resources that answer common questions and address objections before they’re raised. Examples include buying guides, ROI calculators, buyer checklists, educational webinars, and industry-specific case studies. These tools let potential clients explore your value proposition at their own pace and build early trust—making it more likely they’ll reach out when ready, on their terms.

WILL YOU GET A SEAT AT THE TABLE?

Perhaps most eye-opening: 85% of buyers have already defined their purchase requirements before speaking with a rep. This includes scope of services, compliance needs, technology platforms, and pricing expectations.

That leaves little room to shift a buyer’s direction during a sales conversation. If your offering doesn’t match—or is misunderstood due to unclear messaging—you may not even get a shot.

Implication for PEOs: Your website, social presence, and marketing materials must clearly communicate your offerings and differentiators before a conversation starts. Ask yourself: Can a visitor understand what makes your PEO unique within five minutes? Are your solutions clearly aligned with their size, industry, or stage of growth? These are the moments that determine whether you’re considered—or passed over.

ALIGNING MARKETING AND SALES FOR THE NEW BUYER JOURNEY

This shift doesn’t mean sales is obsolete—it means sales and marketing must work in lockstep. In a consultative industry like PEO, aligning both teams around a shared understanding of today’s buyer is critical.

Here are four ways to bridge that gap:

  1. Collaborate on Content Development. Your sales team knows the questions prospects ask. Use that insight to create proactive content—blogs, videos, webinars, white papers—that support each stage of the funnel.
  2. Adopt an ABM (Account-Based Marketing) Mindset. Instead of casting a wide net, focus on high-fit accounts with personalized outreach, relevant content, and coordinated sales-marketing touchpoints. ABM makes you relevant before buyers engage.
  3. Invest in Buyer Enablement Tools. Give buyers the tools they need to make internal decisions—think side-by-side service comparisons, implementation guides, or executive-ready summaries.
  4. Measure What Matters. Go beyond lead counts and track engagement signals that reveal buying intent—time on key pages, repeat visits, downloads. These can indicate where a buyer is in their journey and guide smarter outreach.

FINAL THOUGHTS: MEETING THE BUYER WHERE THEY ARE

The PEO market is evolving—and so are its buyers. CEOs, HR leaders, and CFOs are doing their homework. They’re informed, confident, and looking for partners who align with pre-set expectations.

Sales isn’t going away—but it must become more adaptive, strategic, and marketing-informed. In many cases, your most effective sales rep is your content and online presence.

If you want to grow your book of business, stop chasing prospects—and start helping them find you. Because by the time they call, they’ve likely already decided whether you’re a contender—or not.

THREE GROWTH CHALLENGES AND SOLUTIONS FOR PEOS

The PEO industry continues to experience rapid expansion, creating new opportunities and challenges for providers. As demand for outsourced HR services grows, PEOs must balance scalability with operational efficiency while also addressing workforce shortages and regulatory complexities. Staying ahead in this evolving landscape requires strategic planning and the adoption of innovative solutions that drive growth and enhance operational performance.

Beyond technology, PEOs should look for partners that provide comprehensive support services to help them scale successfully. Managed services, education programs, sales enablement, marketing support and high-touch customer service play a critical role in ensuring operational efficiency and long-term success. By leveraging these additional resources, PEOs can enhance their value proposition, strengthen client relationships and maintain a competitive edge.

HIRING TALENT

PEOs are seeing firsthand the impact of ongoing labor shortages, particularly in the professional and business sectors, which has the highest number of job openings according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. To help their clients attract and retain top talent, PEOs need to provide more than just applicant tracking systems (ATS) and automated hiring tools. Industry experts emphasize that expanding hiring strategies to include global and nearshore talent pools is becoming a top priority. By facilitating international hiring and compliance through partner companies, PEOs can offer their clients access to a broader, cost-effective workforce. Additionally, by leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) in recruitment PEOs can enhance efficiency by automating résumé sorting, job descriptions and candidate matching.

OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY

Time is money and ensuring optimal operational efficiency will be key for PEOs looking to expand their business. To support growth while maintaining high service levels, PEOs must optimize their internal operations. According to insights from industry leaders, the focus is shifting toward integrating advanced workforce management platforms that not only streamline payroll and HR processes but also provide real-time data for better decision-making. Enhanced automation, self-service tools and AI-driven insights are helping PEOs improve efficiency, reduce costs and enhance the overall client experience. Additionally, as PEO client companies expand their hiring reach into global markets, integrating global workforce solutions (tech and services), such as EOR and global payroll, will automate processes and enhance competitiveness.

VENDOR MANAGEMENT

As PEOs grow, so often does the number of vendors they work with. Managing multiple vendors remains a challenge as PEOs scale their services. Feedback from sales and operation teams suggest that consolidation is a key strategy for driving efficiency. A PEO may work with separate providers for payroll, benefits and compliance, but relying on disparate systems can create inefficiencies for both the PEO and its clients. By moving to a single, integrated HR technology provider, PEOs can reduce administrative burdens and provide a seamless experience for their clients. Industry-leading HR software providers have spent decades refining solutions tailored to the PEO market, ensuring that growth does not come at the cost of operational complexity.

As the PEO industry continues to evolve, the need for proactive strategies to address workforce shortages, improve operational efficiency and streamline vendor management is more important than ever. By adopting forward-thinking solutions and optimizing key business processes, PEOs can strengthen their market position and better support their clients in an increasingly complex employment landscape.

EDUCATE, RETAIN, & EXPAND: 3 STEPS TO GUIDE YOUR PEO GROWTH JOURNEY

The PEO business has been good. I’ve enjoyed my career in this field, and I am energized to help all parties reap the benefits that a PEO offers. But did you know that only 17% of US companies with 10-99 employees currently use a PEO? A tremendous potential for growth exists in the marketplace, and PEO professionals should prepare themselves now to leverage the opportunities for expansion.

Eighty-three percent of the PEO target market, over a million small businesses, are virtually untapped. That doesn’t even include tiny startup organizations.

These organizations may be unaware of how PEOs can save them money, offload troublesome administrative duties, and provide their employees with benefits that rival large firms. It is up to the PEO industry to educate and inform this large group of potential customers.

Increasing the number of companies using PEO services isn’t just good for PEO providers and others in the PEO supply chain. The act of engaging with a PEO has a positive effect on many organizations. A recent study by NAPEO compared companies who do not use PEOs, to PEO clients. The PEO clients:

  • Have a growth rate that is over 2 times higher
  • Have an employee turnover rate that is 12 percent lower
  • Are 50 percent less likely to go out of business

Partly because of their use of PEO services, NAPEO says, companies are more stable, robust businesses that are better positioned for long-term success.

STRATEGIES FOR PEO INDUSTRY EXPANSION

With such a large potential on the horizon, it makes sense to encourage people working in the PEO industry to take the steps necessary to execute the growth strategies. We can divide this preparation into three categories: education & training, client retention, and complementary services.

EDUCATION AND TRAINING

Some people on the front lines are not fully informed about how PEOs work, when they are a good fit for a company, or how to choose the right plan for a client.

Trusted advisors such as insurance brokers, CPAs, or labor lawyers may be unaware of how to recognize a PEO opportunity. There are no PEO education actions that professionals in the CPA profession or the employee benefits world are required to take. They are not talking to their clients about PEOs because they don’t know enough. With more education and consistent reinforcement from the PEO community, these professionals would naturally recommend or refer their clients to PEOs more often.

This approach works. I have educated over a thousand insurance brokers about PEO sales strategy, opportunity, and approaches. I built training modules that helped learners be confident and competent in starting business conversations about PEO service providers, their platforms, carriers, and industry target markets. These trained individuals now include PEO topics in their client meetings more often.

NAPEO offers a wide range of educational materials for its members, including PEO University courses, webinars, virtual events, and live events, such as the Annual Conference and Marketplace. Outreach programs aimed at professionals outside the NAPEO membership would expose these individuals to PEO basics and allow the advisors a chance to network with experienced PEO veterans.

CLIENT RETENTION

Growth entails more than acquiring new clients. PEOs must also be adept at retaining their existing customers. Client retention strategies may include moves to communicate better with customers about medical plan rate changes or payroll administration. This improves the customer experience throughout the term of the PEO contract.

With benefit costs rising, renewal time is a point of vulnerability for insurance brokers. Clients unhappy with large health insurance premium increases quoted at renewal may decide to shop around with another broker. If the broker is informed about PEOs and connected to PEO advisors, however, they can often propose benefit plans purchased through a PEO at substantial savings and avert the loss of a client.

Trusted advisors can achieve customer communication improvements with targeted informational content and regularly scheduled executive meetings. Keeping clients informed of events and trends as they occur is more effective than waiting to address numerous questions at renewal time. PEOs must reach out to clients in the months leading up to renewal dates, allowing them to identify any issues or head off competitors.

EXPAND WITH COMPLEMENTARY SERVICES

Additional value-added services make it easier to sell against the competition and add worth to a PEO relationship. Some additional services PEOs can offer include embedded accounting tools or expanded compliance assistance.

Accounting services can help clients manage their finances more efficiently by integrating with the PEO platform. Access to compliance assistance helps companies deal with complex employment laws or regulatory compliance.

Other complementary services PEOs could offer might include international HR assistance, outplacement services, or executive coaching.

SALES AND MARKETING APPROACHES

To sell PEO services to a plentiful market, PEOs should consider the trusted advisors as an outside sales force. Just as they do with their own captive sales team, PEOs can actively help trusted advisors be successful in selling more PEO plans. These people already have relationships with companies who would benefit from a PEO relationship. Those companies just need their advisors to show them how PEOs will benefit the company.

PEOs have a financial interest in helping individuals like insurance brokers and CPAs sell more PEOs. They may need to consider offering incentives like higher commissions or bonuses to convince these professionals to talk with their clients about PEOs more often.

PEO education for advisors should be proactively pushed to those individuals. Everyone is busy. Waiting for insurance brokers to seek education on their own seems unreasonable. Treating independent advisors more like a sales force will prompt PEOs to roll out a strategy with resources, targets, deadlines, and result tracking.

A major hurdle to overcome is a perceived complexity surrounding underwriting and plan onboarding. PEO experts can expose the advisors to human helpers and platforms designed to make the PEO sales process easier.

TRUSTED ADVISORS: A CRITICAL KEY TO PEO EXPANSION

Advisors, such as accountants or insurance brokers, have earned a position of trust with companies that may benefit from PEO services. Given the size of the potential market among small businesses, these professionals are poised to reap the benefits of leveraging those relationships to inform and educate their clients about PEOs.

Organizations such as NAPEO, and support by PEO professionals and outside influencers, can help trusted advisors learn about PEOs. They can become familiar with the education resources, tools, and support it takes to increase their sales and grow the PEO market.

40 LESSONS IN 40 YEARS OF SELLING HRO AND LEADING HRO SALES TEAMS

It is unfathomable to see how far the industry has come, as well as my own personal journey. I am eternally grateful for the opportunity to have learned so much from so many incredible people. This article could easily contain 400 lessons. It is my sincerest hope that you will find value in the following 40 lessons in selling and leading your team.

NAPEO’S 2024 PEO AWARENESS SURVEY UNVEILED

Since 2018, NAPEO has partnered with market research firm Povaddo to track PEO awareness among business owners and key decision makers. The 2024 survey found that PEO awareness now stands at 67%, a 48% increase since 2018.

THE CRITICAL ROLE FOR PEOS IN MAXIMIZING EMPLOYEE CARE

Amid an ever-shifting set of challenges — from rising costs to changing consumer preferences and generational shifts in the workplace — employers now face a “permacrisis.” The formerly unprecedented has become the norm, ramping up pressure on employers to devise new strategies to safeguard their talent and grow their business.

How to Actuarially Drive Sales

Leveraging actuarial skills and data-driven strategies is like having a GPS for your sales journey. It helps PEOs target the right markets, optimize profitability, tailor pricing, and continuously improve.

BEYOND BENEFITS SAVINGS: THE EVOLUTION OF SELLING PEO

Just as the HR landscape has shifted significantly in the last 25 years, so has the value of a PEO’s services to prospective clients. Two decades ago, most prospective clients came to us for one reason. They were motivated by the cost savings a PEO could provide on employee benefits.

WATCH YOUR LANGUAGE 

Here are 7 recommendations for having better communications to gain deeper, authentic relationships and more client relationships along the way.

ON THE SAME PAGE: ALIGNING PEO SALES AND MARKETING TEAMS

While marketing and sales serve distinct functions, their objectives are essentially the same: to attract, engage, and retain clients. When these functions operate in silos, it can lead to inefficiencies, missed opportunities, and, ultimately, poor client experience.

HOW PEOS CAN RECALIBRATE FOR THE CHANGING CONSUMER LANDSCAPE

Although there are over 500 PEOs in the U.S. assisting more than 200,000 small businesses, the landscape has changed. Changes in human resources, labor laws, job-searching processes, technology and talent demand have all impacted how PEOs provide solutions and help employer clients.

MIND THE GAP: WHAT YOU’RE NOT OFFERING CAN HURT YOU

To remain competitive and keep clients, PEOs must address these critical gaps in HR analytics, platform scalability and data security. By enhancing their service offerings in these areas, PEOs will better meet the evolving needs of their HR clients, ensuring sustained strategy, scale, security and satisfaction.