UNDERSTANDING THE ROLE OF THE PEO BROKER IN THE EVOLVING INDUSTRY LANDSCAPE

BY NATE OLSEN

President
BestFit PEO Solutions

November 2025

 

The PEO industry has advanced and developed over the years by helping businesses of all sizes access world-class HR, regulatory compliance, and benefits support. Today, as the marketplace matures further and competition expands, a new partner is emerging as an increasingly important part of the PEO ecosystem: the PEO broker.

Much like the way financial advisors help individuals navigate investment options, PEO brokers guide businesses through the increasingly crowded and sometimes confusing PEO marketplace. With more than 500 PEOs operating across the United States, ranging from the largest national firms to niche providers specializing in individual industries or offerings, the sheer number of choices can be overwhelming for some small and medium-sized businesses. This is where brokers are providing a valuable resource for both companies and PEOs alike.

A GROWING MARKET OF PEO BROKERS

The community of PEO brokers has increased steadily in recent years, reflecting a broader shift in how companies approach HR outsourcing decisions. Rather than relying solely on their own limited research or defaulting to the most recognizable names, businesses are increasingly looking for an informed, unbiased partner to help them identify the best HR services provider for their needs.

PEO brokers serve as an extension of a company’s leadership and HR teams, doing the heavy lifting to quickly and efficiently evaluate providers, compare service models, and deliver customized recommendations. This is particularly beneficial for small and mid-size businesses, which often lack the resources or expertise to conduct a thorough search of PEO options on their own.

THE MANY REASONS WHY COMPANIES ARE INCREASINGLY PARTNERING WITH PEO BROKERS

In many cases, the person who oversees a company’s HR functions or the organization’s CFO is tasked with finding the first or next PEO for a business. However, even highly seasoned professionals can run into issues. The most well-known PEOs or those that promote attractive pricing models often do not fit a company’s unique needs. On top of that, the individuals tasked with locating a PEO are not always certain they are aware of all the right questions to ask. Many are fearful of hidden costs or failing to confirm the availability of certain services that are highly valued by employees. Other times, they simply feel like they could use a better overall understanding of the PEO industry and worry there are better, harder to locate HR partner options out there that are more likely to fit the current needs of their organization.

There’s also the time commitment. Thoroughly investigating all the possibilities can take several days or even weeks. It often requires web research, talking to sales staff and creating comparison spreadsheets to help leaders make an informed choice. The tensions caused by conducting a search while performing other critical business tasks can leave some professionals feeling less confident about the search process and their eventual decision.

In comparison, PEO brokers offer a valuable, time-saving solution. They can sort through hundreds of options – instead of limiting their search to the largest firms, brokers consider the full spectrum of providers, including industry-specific PEOs with specialized expertise. Some PEOs focus primarily on serving the medical field, construction, or even tech-forward companies. The options are nearly endless.

A broker can offer customized recommendations by assessing a business’s size, industry, and goals, matching companies with PEOs that best align with their needs. Brokers also know how to streamline the evaluation process, allowing HR and leadership departments to maintain their focus on their strategic initiatives until it’s time to sit down to look at the data and make an informed choice.

MAXIMIZING BENEFITS FOR THE PEO COMMUNITY

While there are numerous reasons why businesses are increasingly partnering with brokers, PEOs also benefit from these relationships as well. PEO brokers serve as an additional channel for connecting PEOs with companies that are well-matched to their offerings. This cannot only shorten the sales cycle, it also has the potential of improving long-term client satisfaction. Companies with well-matched PEOs are more likely to provide positive feedback and retain a partner that truly fits their needs.

Brokers also help expand the reach of smaller or specialized PEOs that may not have the same brand recognition as other HR service providers. By bringing these unique offerings to the forefront, brokers contribute to a more diverse PEO marketplace, ultimately benefiting the PEO industry as a whole.

LOOKING AHEAD

As the demand for PEO services continues to grow, so too will the need for trusted advisors who can help businesses make informed decisions. PEO brokers are filling that role, serving as a bridge between businesses seeking PEO solutions and the providers best equipped to meet those needs.

As the PEO landscape evolves, brokers are becoming an integral part of the HR services ecosystem, ensuring that businesses locate the right PEO partner as the industry continues to expand its reach, services and profitability.

SHARE


RELATED ARTICLES

CLIENT-LEVEL FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

If you asked someone in the PEO space what he or she thought of actuarial science a positive response might be reserve analyses or accruals. A negative response might be collateral calls or rate increases. Naturally, the varied reactions stem from whether there is positive or negative news coming from the work of the actuary. Yet, one of the most helpful projects an actuary can perform for a PEO, eliciting either positive and negative reactions, is a client-level financial analysis.  

BY FRANK HUANG

June/July 2023

PROFITABILITY ABCs: IT IS AS EASY AS 1-2-3

The article provides some simple guidance for streamlining operations (thus reducing selling, general, and administrative (SGA) costs) and increasing gross profit contribution from their existing client base. For the purpose of this article, we are only exploring pricing strategies that affect client profitability and operating efficiency items that impact select SG&A cost categories. Business development and organic growth are excluded from this discussion.  

BY Dan McHenry

June/July 2023

THE 5 Ws OF PEO GENERAL LEDGER RECONCILIATIONS

General ledger reconciliation is a key control to help maintain timely and accurate financial statements in any business. If you speak to accounting or finance professionals in the PEO industry, they will agree that general ledger balance sheet reconciliations are the most telling and critical tools in analyzing a PEO’s fiscal position. Failure to reconcile balance sheet accounts timely and accurately can lead to material losses to the PEO. Let’s explore the 5 W’s of PEO ledger reconciliations.  

BY JEAN GOLDSTEIN

JUNE/JULY 2023
FINANCE - OPERATIONS

UTILIZING METRICS AS A PATH TO IMPROVING OPERATIONALLY OVER TIME

A company’s story is often written succinctly on its website, with details of the company’s history, its values, and its aspirations for the future. Internally, however, company leaders can capture a more telling story. Operational metrics, while often unique to each company, depict a different story.

BY Aaron Call

September 2023

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad for Sentara Health Plans